Hard maple resists dents, white oak shrugs off moisture with stubborn rays, and black walnut brings strength wrapped in warmth. Cherry deepens beautifully, rewarding patience with color that quietly ripens. Softer woods can be excellent too when used appropriately, but mismatches betray rushed thinking. Ask why a maker chose this species for legs, that for drawer sides, and another for runners. The best answers connect wear, stability, and beauty without compromise.
Quartersawn oak resists cupping while displaying shimmering medullary rays; rift-sawn stock offers uniform lines perfect for legs; plain-sawn boards can sing on wide panels when balanced with proper joinery. Good makers align grain direction to directions of expected stress, minimizing movement headaches later. Flip a piece and study growth rings at edges. Are predictable movements allowed? When wood is oriented wisely, doors stay true, tabletops stay flatter, and repairs remain mercifully rare.
Run fingertips across a tabletop and notice whether the surface feels calm, not furry or gritty. Proper sanding follows a logical progression, erasing scratches rather than hiding them. Hand planing leaves faint, elegant scallops that catch light without chatter. End grain should be burnished and sealed to avoid thirsty blotches. Inside corners and drawer interiors matter too, staying smooth without thick finish streaks. Real care reveals itself where shortcuts are easiest to hide.
Depth comes from thoughtful layering: perhaps a dye to even tone, shellac to lock color, and an oil-varnish blend for resilience. Chatoyance should shimmer rather than sit behind plastic sheen. Blotch-prone woods like cherry or maple need controlled sealing, not heavy pigment that smothers figure. UV stability matters near windows. A piece that looks honest under morning light, evening warmth, and gray weather is likely balanced well enough to please for decades.
Thin, well-leveled coats beat thick, impatient floods every time. Look inside corners for consistent sheen, spot runs before they harden into regrets, and notice whether backs and undersides received appropriate protection. Dust nibs should be leveled between coats without wiping through edges. Allow proper cure times so drawers do not stick and surfaces do not print. A finish that feels dry yet lively under your hand signals discipline, patience, and respect for the material.